6 Best Coffee Choices For Keurig Reusable K-Cups

Using a Keurig reusable coffee pod helps reduce your waste, but what coffee can you use? We’ve compiled the best coffee choices for Keurig reusable K-cups.

Best coffee choices for Keurig reusable
Reusable coffee pod helps reduce your waste

Although the Keurig Coffee company was founded in 1992, it didn’t really take off until the mid-2000s with the introduction of at-home brewing machines. These coffee makers could brew individual cups with plastic containers called K-pods. Unfortunately, as single-use plastics, these pods have contributed more than their share of waste over the years. 

I love having a Keurig, but I felt bad about using so much plastic. Fortunately, the reusable Keurig pod came out a few years ago, meaning I could get the convenience of the machine without the guilt. Another benefit of using a reusable pod is that you can fill it with any type of coffee, not just those that you can find in pod form. 

If you’re using a Keurig machine, you’ll want to know the best coffee options for your reusable pod. From dark roast to light, this is the best coffee for Keurig reusable K-cups. You might also be interested in our round-up of the best sustainable coffee brands

1. Lion French Roast

All coffee connoisseurs know that it’s an expensive habit. If you drop into your local coffee shop on the way to work each morning and again on your break, you’ll be horrified when you total up how much you spent on coffee in one year. So, the best thing about Keurig reusable K-cups is you can save money by brewing a good cup of Joe with you and bringing it with you in a thermos.

I prefer smoother, creamier roasts, so something like Lion French Roast does the trick while still being quite affordable per ounce. When you consider how little coffee you need to make a single cup, one bag can go a long way. 

2. LaVazza Super Crema 

Coffee grounds are best in a Keurig reusable pod. I prefer to get whole beans that I can grind myself, so I’m in total control of the situation. However, if you prefer to avoid the idea of grinding beans every morning (or afternoon), pre-ground coffee is much more convenient. 

Hot cup of coffee with coffee beans and ground coffee beside
Coffee grounds are best in a Keurig reusable pod

Plus, whole beans preserve more of the nutrients and flavors of the coffee. I noticed an immediate difference once I started grinding my own beans, and I’ve never looked back. 

If you like Italian coffee, Lavazza is an excellent brand. The Super Crema beans are actually a blend of different plants from various Latin American countries like Brazil and Colombia. The flavor is superb and goes down smoother than most other coffee I’ve tried. 

3. Lifeboost Midnight Dark Roast

When choosing any kind of coffee, the roast level is crucial for ensuring that you’ll enjoy the flavor or not. Dark roasted beans have been roasted longer, so they’re not as acidic, and they have more of a richer, bolder flavor. 

The Lifeboost dark roast coffee is a bit darker and bolder than others I’ve experienced, but I enjoy how it makes me feel alert and ready to face the day. Lifeboost is also an excellent brand that focuses on organic and Fair Trade practices. 

Lifeboost Coffee Dark Roast Ground Coffee - Low Acid Single Origin USDA Organic Coffee - Non-GMO Ground Coffee Beans Dark Roast Third Party Tested For Mycotoxins & Pesticides - 12 Ounces
$27.95 ($2.33 / Ounce)
  • Delicious, Ethically Sourced Coffee: You've tried the rest, now buy the best ground coffee on the market; This Non-Gmo organic low acid coffee is high in flavor; The beans are sun dried, and spring water washed; The result is pure, natural coffee derived straight from nature
  • Grown In The Mountains Of Central America: Lifeboost Single Origin Acid Free Coffee is shade grown at a high elevation in the mountains of Central America. The exclusive farms that we work with are all bird friendly and each coffee bean is hand selected to ensure purity
  • Low Acid Coffee Ground Dark Roast: Your standard cup of coffee is very acidic; That's why some feel stomach discomfort or deal with teeth issues from drinking coffee; The solution is our low acid coffee beans; The antioxidant rich organic coffee delivers all the wonderful benefits of coffee without the unwanted side effects
  • Certified Organic & 3rd Party Tested: Lifeboost Organic Coffee Ground Beans are Usda Certified Organic, and 3rd Party Tested for mycotoxins, heavy metals, pesticides, and 400 other toxins; One sip of this organic ground coffee and you'll have a hard time going back to an ordinary cup of joe
  • Love It Or You Don't Owe Us A Dime: Nothing makes us happier than hearing how much our customers love our award winning coffee; We're confident you'll be another that agrees that we have the best coffee beans; Try a bag out for 30 days, and if you don't love this coffee (we doubt it), we'll give you your money back

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
03/30/2023 05:22 pm GMT

4. Caribou Coffee Medium Roast

Caribou Coffee‘s medium roast makes you feel like you’re camping out in the wilderness with only your wits and tools to keep you alive. Caribou is relatively mild, but it has a strong finish that’s sure to wake you up in the morning like a brisk winter breeze. This coffee is also versatile as you can use it in a Keurig or other coffee makers, like a French press. 

Caribou Coffee, Medium Roast Ground Coffee - Caribou Blend 20 Ounce Bag
$12.99 ($0.65 / Ounce)
  • Contains one (1) 20 Ounce Bag of Caribou Coffee Caribou Blend Medium Roast Ground Coffee
  • Caribou Blend: Medium Roast with a combination of sweet, spicy, and berry notes, Caribou Blend is harmoniously balanced for a relaxing, down-to-earth cup
  • Quality Ingredients: Rainforest Alliance certified, 100% Arabica coffee, small batch roasted and hand-packed in Minneapolis
  • Brewing Methods: Our ground coffee is formulated to make drip or a pour over in your Chemex. For other brewing methods - espresso, cold brew, or French press - consider our whole bean coffee and griding at home
  • About Caribou: Coffee isn't just our business, it's our unrelenting passion. We love to roast it, brew it, smell it, and (DUH) drink it. But most of all, we love how it brings people together and inspires adventure, big and small

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
03/30/2023 04:27 pm GMT

5. Eight O’Clock Coffee Donut Shop 

Light roasts are great for those who like bright, fruity coffee and are not adverse to a little acidity. If Caribou Coffee makes you feel like you’re waking up in the great outdoors, Eight O’Clock Coffee’s Donut Shop transports you to a diner where you can enjoy a sweet donut with your cup of Joe. This light roast pairs perfectly well with coffee cake and, of course, a donut. 

Eight O'Clock Coffee Donut Shop, Mild Roast, 100% Arabica Ground Coffee, Kosher Certified, 11 Oz
$9.69 ($0.88 / Ounce)
  • GREAT TASTING Coffee for over 100 years – Winey notes and a rich, elegant aroma with a full-bodied finish. All of roasting is done at our own facility in Maryland, USA
  • MILD ROASTED COFFEE: Perfect complement to a glazed treat and perfect choice for the "dunker" In your house
  • BALANCED FLAVORS: Classically smooth and has an incredibly well balanced flavor
  • QUALITY GUARANTEED: 100% Arabica beans for premium quality and taste, Kosher certified
  • COMMITMENT TO ENVIRONMENT: Through partnerships with different coffee organizations, we hope to support the coffee farming community with the goal to help improve the quality of life for all people involved in the coffee supply chain

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
03/30/2023 04:52 pm GMT

6. Volcanica House Blend

Personally, I don’t see the appeal of decaf coffee, but I know that many people drink it, especially at night when winding down after a long day. If you’re one of those people, you want to focus more on the flavor of the coffee. So, smoother blends that have a full-bodied taste can deliver better results than cheap decaf that can go down pretty harshly. 

Asian senior man with vintage coffee grinder
Need to use a coffee grinder at home to drink it

For this, the Volcanica House Blend is your best bet. Volcanica is an excellent coffee company focusing on small batches of high-quality beans. This particular version has whole beans, so you need to use a coffee grinder at home to drink it.

However, the flavor profile is superb, and you can feel good as they’re a pretty ethical brand.

Volcanica House Decaf Coffee, Whole Bean, Swiss Water Processed, Fresh Roasted, 16-ounce
$25.99 ($1.62 / Ounce)
  • Volcanica Decaf House Blend Coffee is an exquisite blend of South and Central American coffees
  • Distinguishable by its sweet yet bold flavor and full rich body.
  • Medium roasted beans allowing the true flavor characteristic to come through for a remarkable taste.
  • Decaffeination by the Swiss Water Process: 100% chemical free process that delivers coffee that is 99.9% caffeine-free while protecting the unique origin characteristics this Sumatran Mandheling coffee.
  • 100% Customer Satisfaction Guaranteed.

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
03/30/2023 04:47 pm GMT

FAQs About The Best Coffee For Keurig Reusable K-Cups

What Is A Keurig Reusable K-cup?

Instead of a small plastic container, a Keurig reusable pod uses metal mesh to filter coffee grounds and deliver the same brewing experience as a regular pod. Reusable models come in different shapes and sizes, and while they’re not infinitely reusable, they can help you cut down on your plastic waste by a substantial margin. 
Overall, a Keurig reusable pod works the same way as a regular drip coffee machine. However, instead of buying filters all the time, the mesh screen does the work for you. Also, even though the mesh is relatively small, these pods are pretty easy to clean. If you buy dishwasher-safe models, you can keep them in pristine condition for a long time.

How To Choose The Best Coffee For Keurig Reusable K-Cups?

Technically, any ground coffee can work in a Keurig reusable pod. However, finding the “best” ground coffee depends on various factors. Overall, when choosing the best coffee for a Keurig, you should focus on the price, whether the coffee is whole bean or pre-ground, the roast level, and whether the coffee is caffeinated. 

What Grind Is Best For Keurig Reusable K-Cups?

You want to use coarse coffee grounds. If you use smaller particles, they can get stuck in the mesh, leading to less brewed coffee and a bigger mess to clean up later. 

What Roast Is Best For Keurig Reusable Pods?

When choosing any kind of coffee, the roast level is crucial for ensuring that you’ll enjoy the flavor or not. Dark roasted beans have been roasted longer, so they’re not as acidic, and they have more of a richer, bolder flavor. Medium roasts are not quite as intense, but they can be slightly more acidic.
Light-roast coffees are the least processed, so they’re the most acidic and often have fruitier tasting notes. 
As for the Keurig reusable pods, you can use any roast as long as the coffee is the right consistency. It’s all about your personal preferences.