5 Best Alternatives To Half-And-Half In Your Coffee

Having the same dairy product for your cup of Joe over and over will not enhance your coffee experience. Read on to find out the best alternatives to half-and-half in your coffee.

Pretty girl in eyeglasses and striped shirt holding milk bottle - Alternatives To Half-And-Half In Your Coffee
Finding the best alternative for half-and-half

We had a family gathering a few months back to celebrate my mother’s birthday. She’s trying to lose some weight, so my brother and I used half-and-half for her macaroni soup and Alfredo sauce (her recipe, of course). 

Yes, you guessed it, we ran out of half-and-half, and I couldn’t find any sort of creamer in the house for my usual afternoon Breve coffee. My brother, ever the genius, gave coconut milk as an alternative. Suffice to say; it was a revelation. 

Thus, my search for the best alternatives to half-and-half began. I won’t be able to live with myself if I don’t share my findings. 

1. Evaporated Milk

This has to be the most common substitute for half-and-half. People from the old days used this as the alternative back when creamer wasn’t a widespread concept yet as it’s often available in every household. You can just make one yourself if you don’t have it yourself, although the process will take time.

You might find this too plain for your taste, but you’d be surprised how it works with coffee. It tastes more concentrated than bland old milk and refreshing to the palette. It still gives your beverage that desired thick and creamy texture.

2. Oat Milk

Want to go even healthier? How about going for oat milk? Given that it’s whole-grain and contains fiber, it’s an alternative packed with protein and calcium and promotes a healthy digestive system to boot.

oat milk in tall drinking glass
Oatmilk is packed with protein and calcium

Most brands offer additional nutrients to their oat milk, such as vitamin A, B, and B-12. It has a natural thickness that will complement your coffee well!

If this is your first time trying it, I highly suggest going for Oatly Oat Milk Barista Edition. If you want something thicker and richer, try Califia Farms Protein Oat Milk

Oatly Oat Milk Barista, 32 Ounce (6 Pack) Gluten-Free, Dairy-Free, Sugar-Free, Non GMO, Vegan, High Fiber, Calcium & Vitamin Enriched
  • Delicious Barista Edition Oatmilk made from gluten-free oats
  • Cool for vegans and non-vegans
  • Natural beta-glucans, plus added calcium and vitamins (A, D, riboflavin, B12)
  • No added sugar, dairy, soy, nuts, thickeners, gums, or annoying GMOs
  • Made with the planet in mind
Sale
Califia Farms - Oat Milk, Unsweetened Barista Blend, 32 Fl Oz (Pack of 6) | Shelf Stable | Non Dairy Milk | Creamer | Vegan | Plant Based | Gluten-Free | Non-GMO
  • Our popular Oat milk barista blend - Steams beautifully, perfectly pairs with coffee and tastes delicious by itself. Milk or Creamer you choose
  • Made from North American grown whole rolled, gluten free oats
  • Unsweetened. State of Readiness: Ready to Drink
  • No gums or stabilizers
  • Nut free, allergen-free, soy free, non-GMO Project Verified, gluten-free, kosher and shelf stable

3. Yogurt

I can sense that you’re squirming already, but hear me out first! Yogurt is a dairy product in the first place, so this idea should not be weird at all. I like this one because it gives your coffee a bit of a twist in terms of flavor; it’s a bit tangy but surprisingly pleasant to your tongue.

Plain yogurt can be bland, but it perfectly complements the bitterness of the coffee, and it still provides that creaminess that half-and-half offers. There’s a thick aftertaste that, based on experience, prolongs that coffee taste in your mouth. Understandably, you’ll have mixed feelings about this, but I suggest you try it for yourself before coming up with a conclusion. 

There will be times that some residues will float, so I suggest you have a sizable mug to mix this with your coffee thoroughly.

4. Coconut Milk

The coconut tree is called the Tree of Life for a reason, and I’m convinced it’s because of the milky-white liquid extracted from its fruit. This creamy and rich beverage is, in itself, a tasty and refreshing beverage. Adding it to coffee infuses that tropical and rejuvenating taste that no creamer or half-and-half can provide.

Coconut milk is lactose and dairy-free

What’s better about this substitute is that since it’s also from a plant, it’s naturally lactose-free and dairy-free, a suitable alternative for coffee lovers who are lactose-intolerant and allergic to milk. I recommend trying So Delicious’ Coconut Milk and checking if it suits your taste for first-timers.

A word of caution – try to heat the coconut milk first for around three to five minutes before putting it in your hot coffee, as there are instances it will curdle. And please, don’t microwave your carton of coconut milk. Put it in a container or mug that’s microwave-safe.

So Delicious Dairy-Free Organic Coconutmilk Beverage, Unsweetened, 32 oz (Pack of 6) Plant-Based Vegan Dairy Alternative, Great in Smoothies Protein Shakes or Cereal
  • DELICIOUS & ORGANIC: Slide over soymilk & move over milk, So Delicious Unsweetened Coconutmilk is here! This delicious beverage goes great over cereal, in coffee, mixed into recipes & poured into a tall glass. It's vegan, gluten & soy free & organic.
  • THE GOOD STUFF: This smooth, creamy, tasty, dairy-free beverage blends excellently in an array of delicious drinks, from smoothies to lattes to milkshakes. You can also use it in baked goods, desserts and other dishes to create vegan, dairy-free delights
  • ONLY THE FINEST INGREDIENTS: We use the highest quality ingredients & our entire line of dairy-free foods & beverages is plant-based, certified vegan, Non-GMO Project verified & cholesterol free. We use no artificial flavors, colors or hydrogenated oils
  • DAIRY FREE DELIGHT: Enjoy life with So Delicious dairy-free delights for every part of your day. We offer an array of dairy-free products you can feel good about: coffee creamers, beverages, yogurt alternatives, frozen desserts, mousses & cheese shreds
  • ALWAYS DAIRY FREE: So Delicious has been bringing joy to dairy-free lives for nearly 30 years. Whether you're cooking a chocolate custard or blending up a protein shake, So Delicious has a dairy free almondmilk, cashewmilk or coconutmilk product for you.

5. Cornstarch & Milk

We often use these two to thicken our soups and sauces; it’s a substitute for heavy cream. So, I wondered why not try it in coffee? I can honestly say the results were a bit surprising.

It’s bland since it’s just milk and starch, so I may suggest adding a sweetener (honey or sugar substitutes). What’s great about this is its flexibility. You can gauge how thick you want your milk to be by just adding more cornstarch.

It will require work, though. You have to heat the milk in a pan on medium-low and slowly incorporate the cornstarch while mixing. I do away with the cooking, and just a bit of cornstarch with leftover milk will do the trick.

Author

  • His love for java originated from sidewalk vendors offering cheap 3-in-1 instant coffees poured in styrofoam cups. If he’s not in a studio or in an event venue, you’ll find RL crafting his own cold brew or sharing his experiences to fellow coffeephiles.