Tasty Coffee Punch Recipes: Step-By-Step Guide

Whether you're hosting a bridal shower, a holiday brunch, or a New Year's Day party, our coffee punch recipes are something you must try and include in your list.

a delicious coffee punch served on a table - coffee punch recipe
A Coffee Punch is a staple recipe of Southern brunches and parties

If you are not from the Southern United States or familiar with this kind of lifestyle, you may think that it is a huge punch bowl of chocolate milk on the beverage table at the party, but native Southerners may share a knowing smile as they offer up their punch cups to the attendant.

They know that the contents of the punch bowl contain a concoction known as Coffee Punch, a staple recipe of Southern brunches and parties.

Ingredients for Coffee Punch

Appetizing coffee and sweets
Prepare the following ingredients listed

To make a large punch bowl of coffee punch for your next party, you will need the following ingredients:

  • 2 quarts of freshly brewed coffee
  • 1/2 cup sugar
  • 1 quart of coffee-flavored ice cream (you can use vanilla ice cream or chocolate ice cream if desired.)
  • 1 quart of vanilla flavored coffee creamer
  • Whipped cream (for garnish)
  • Shaved or grated semi-sweet chocolate (for garnish)

Step 1. Mix the Coffee and the Sugar

Keeping the coffee hot, stir it together with the granulated sugar in a medium mixing bowl that has a plastic lid. Continue stirring until the sugar is fully dissolved. Cover the mixing bowl with the lid and put it in the refrigerator to chill for about two or three hours.

You can do this step of the recipe the night before, storing the chilled sweetened coffee in the refrigerator overnight. 

Step 2. Mix the Coffee Mixture, Creamer, and Ice Cream

About 10 to 15 minutes before your party is set to begin, pour the coffee mixture into the punch bowl and add the coffee-flavored ice cream and the vanilla flavored coffee creamer to the mixture. Stir the mixture until the ice cream is mostly melted.

Step 3. Add the Whipped Cream and Chocolate

Top the coffee punch mixture with dollops of whipped cream and sprinkle the whipped cream with chocolate shavings as a garnish. 

Step 4. Serve

Ladle the servings of coffee punch into punch bowls and pass them to your party guests. Enjoy the sweet, creamy, and delicious cups of coffee punch.

Coffee Punch Recipe Tweaks

Most coffee punch recipes call for a quart of coffee ice cream. However, if you want to tweak the recipe a bit, you can change the flavor of the ice cream. Vanilla ice cream will give you a milder flavored coffee punch while substituting chocolate ice cream will give you a mocha flavored treat. 

different ice cream flavors in a plate
You can tweak the Coffee Punch recipe by using a different ice cream flavor

You can add a tablespoon of peppermint extract to the coffee mixture if you are hosting a Christmas party. You may want to use peppermint ice cream in place of the coffee-flavored ice cream and top the punch with crushed peppermint candies. 

To create the spiked version of this party favorite, you can add 1/2 to 3/4 cup of coffee-flavored liqueur to the mixture as you add the ice cream. Be sure that party attendees are aware that there is alcohol in the punch so that they will not accidentally overdo it, drinking multiple cups of this delicious punch.

Because the punch is so sweet and flavorful, the flavor of the liqueur may be mostly masked in the punch.

The Nutrition of Coffee Punch Recipes

Let's be honest. With its copious amounts of sugar, ice cream, and coffee creamer, coffee punch is not healthy at all. In fact, this recipe is loaded with calories, fat, and carbohydrates.

However, in every person's diet, space must be made for occasional indulgences. This recipe is one of those that can be enjoyed once a year, one or two cups at a time.

While you would not want to drink multiple cups of this creamy, sweet concoction, as a once in a while treat, this recipe for coffee punch is a great addition to your party menu.

Final Word on Coffee Punch Recipes

This recipe for coffee punch is definitely one to add to your recipe box, particularly if you frequently host parties or entertain large groups of people. With multiple variations, you can tweak this recipe to suit the occasion. Everyone at your party will enjoy the creamy, coffee drink.

FAQs about Coffee Punch Recipes

What is Coffee Punch?

Coffee punch is a delicious, creamy coffee flavored beverage that is frequently served in the South for any kind of social get together. Usually, non-alcoholic coffee punch features coffee, sugar, and flavored coffee creamer. Ice cream is generally included in these easy recipes as well.

If I'm not a coffee drinker, will I still like coffee punch?

Even those who do not care for a cup of coffee often find the coffee punch to be yummy. The coffee is sweetened enough that the coffee flavor is not overwhelming. The flavor of this coffee punch recipe is closer to that of a milkshake than that of a cup of strong coffee.

How long does it take to make coffee punch?

The final mixing of the coffee punch takes about 5 to 10 minutes or less total time. However, you will want to make your hot coffee and sugar mixture about 2 to 3 hours before your party so that it can chill before you mix the ingredients.

Alternately, you can make the hot coffee mixture the day before the party, storing it in the refrigerator to help reduce prep time on the day of your party.

Can I use instant coffee in coffee punch recipes?

If you want to use instant coffee in your coffee punch, you definitely can. Simply dissolve 1 1/2 cups of instant coffee crystals in 2 quarts of boiling water. Chill the coffee as directed and proceed with the recipe instructions.

Author

  • April Freeman is a freelance writer who lives with her husband and children on their Middle Tennessee farm where they raise vegetables, fruit, chickens, and cattle. April enjoys writing about food and is always whipping up something tasty in her kitchen. She also is an avid reader of books of all kinds.