10 Most Popular Coffee Creamer Flavors

Let’s cover the most popular coffee creamer flavors to make your morning coffee more enjoyable than ever. 

Most Popular Coffee Creamer Flavors
Adding a coffee creamer to your cup of joe can make it more delicious and interesting

It’s nice to enjoy a hot cup of coffee in the morning. Many of us love adding a splash of flavored coffee creamer to make that morning cup of joe more interesting. I know I love adding a bit of something creamy and sweet to my coffee, and it’s even better if it has a delicious, unique flavor.

This list of popular creamer flavors comes from some of the best-selling brands in the US, such as Nestle Coffee-Mate, International Cafe, Silk, and Starbucks. Read on to learn more about each flavor and see why it made the list.

1. French Vanilla

French vanilla is usually considered the most classic coffee creamer flavor. The French were the first to flavor ice cream with vanilla, where the name comes from. 

It has remained a popular ice cream flavor for centuries and has made its mark in the coffee creamer world, too. So much so that you can even find ground coffee that comes pre-flavored with French vanilla.

French vanilla differs slightly from plain vanilla. It has a richer, custard-like flavor. Coffee-Mate is the most popular brand of coffee creamer, and they sell more French vanilla than any other flavor. 

2. Cafe Mocha

Cafe Mocha is a flavor that is based on a chocolate-flavored cafe latte. Americans love their chocolate, so it is easy to see how this flavor became so popular. After all, who doesn’t want to feel like they’re having dessert for breakfast?

3. Italian Sweet Cream

This flavor of creamer was inspired by Italian pastry cream that is used in classic Italian desserts. This flavoring is very sweet with notes of vanilla and almond. Italian Sweet Cream is one of Coffee Mate’s most popular flavors and is popular among other brands as well.

This sweet flavor pairs well with more robust roasts. A dark roast would contrast well with its sweetness. 

4. Hazelnut

Hazelnut has long been considered a good pairing with coffee. They both have deep, somewhat chocolatey flavors. A splash of hazelnut coffee creamer will add a rich, bold tone to your morning coffee. Hazelnut is a classic flavor that is very popular among coffee creamers and gives people a touch of nostalgia with every sip.

5. Caramel Macchiato

Caramel Macchiato flavored creamer is derived from a drink with espresso, vanilla, and a caramel drizzle. Starbucks invented its own version of Caramel Macchiato coffee, which became a fan favorite at the chain. Now, they have a creamer with the same delicious flavors as their popular drink.

This flavor is popular across several brands, and it’s not hard to see why. The creamers have a velvety feel with the delicious tastes of both vanilla and caramel. It’s also an easy way for Starbucks lovers to have one of their favorite drinks on a budget. 

6. Creme Brulee

Creme brulee is a classic French dessert that has been popular since the middle ages. It is a baked custard with a broiled brown sugar crust on top. Creamers based on this dessert tend to taste like creamy custard with hints of brown sugar. 

This flavor of creamer is a best-seller at Coffee-Mate and is popular with other brands as well. It has developed a bit of a cult following – likely by dessert lovers!

7. White Chocolate

White chocolate was first made commercially in 1936 in Switzerland. Since then, it has exploded in popularity around the world. White chocolate has a very creamy texture and is usually vanilla-flavored. Those features make it a popular pairing with coffee. 

There are several brands that carry this flavor, though Starbucks is touted as the first to create a creamer based on their popular White Chocolate Mocha drink. 

8. Butter Pecan

Butter pecan is a classic Southern flavor. It is used in cakes, ice cream, and other desserts. It is now also a well-loved flavor for coffee creamers. This creamer flavor tastes like cream and butter, mixed with the nutty flavor of toasted pecans. If you like pecan pies or praline candy, this creamer will speak to you!  

9. Salted Caramel Mocha

It is hard to go wrong with the tried-and-true salty-and-sweet combination. Salted caramel mocha is a creamer flavor that gives salted caramel lovers the daily enjoyment of their favorite candy in a steaming hot mug. Both International Delight and Starbucks have best-selling creamers with this flavor.

10. Pumpkin Spice

Americans seem to have a love affair with pumpkin spice every time the cooler autumn months roll around. This flavor can be found in anything from pies and cakes to coffees and candles. Though pumpkin spice creamer is usually a seasonal item, it’s so popular during those few months each year that it more than earns a secure spot on this list.