Can You Put Eggnog In Coffee? Explained

Eggnog is one of the most popular holiday drinks to enjoy with your family. But can you put eggnog in coffee? Continue reading to find out. 

Eggnog in glasses with fresh vanilla and eggs - Can you put eggnog in coffee
Eggnog can be added in your coffee

Eggnog is not only one of the best traditional holiday drinks. It’s also one of the most controversial. 

It has endearing points; the first US President, George Washington, and his wife Martha created their own recipe. However, during a holiday celebration, it was also involved in a commotion that caused a military riot in 1826 at the US Military Academy in West Point, New York.

In this article, we’ll focus on the drink itself. There are many ways you can enjoy eggnog, and one of them is adding it to your coffee. 

All About Eggnog

Eggnog’s origin is still a mystery and continues to be a topic of debate to many historians. It’s a warm to hot drink made with milk and wine or ale in medieval Britain. The name comes from “noggin” (wooden cup), “grog” (strong beer), and “egg,”  making it “egg-n-grog.” Over time, it became eggnog.

Eggnog is usually made with egg yolk, sugar, milk, heavy cream, and vanilla extract. It occasionally has brandy, grated nutmeg, and cinnamon sticks. It was historically served by wealthy families who hosted large gatherings during holidays because of its expensive ingredients. 

Pot with eggnog, ingredients and spices on wood
Eggnog ingredients include egg yolk, sugar, milk, heavy cream, and vanilla extract

The Taste Of Eggnog

Eggnog is very popular because of its sweet and creamy, custardy flavor complemented by the brandy’s sweet and fruity tones. Its slightly spicy flavor and aroma come from warm spices like nutmeg, cinnamon, cloves, and star anise. When it comes to texture, eggnog is a lot ticker than whole milk, which usually looks like melted vanilla ice cream.

You might also be wondering can you put flaxseed in coffee.

Eggnog With Alcohol And Coffee

Eggnog tastes good with almost any alcohol except tequila. People used brandy such as Sherry and Madeira in the past, but since it was heavily taxed, they changed it into rum until bourbon, made from corn, entered the business and made the drink more popular.

If you want alcohol-free eggnog, you can drink it as is because alcohol is only optional. But keep in mind that vanilla extract can add a small amount of alcohol. 

Eggnog As Coffee Creamer

Eggnog and coffee may not sound like a compatible pair, but when combined, the eggnog will add sweetness and spice to your regular cup of Joe. By adding eggnog to coffee as an alternative to creamer, you can make an eggnog coffee that tastes like ice cream. It’s an excellent way to use leftover eggnog before it expires.

If you are looking for more coffee creamer alternatives, check out the 10 Best Healthy Alternatives For Coffee Creamer.

Serving Size

Because of its thick and creamy texture and unique taste, eggnog is one of the best coffee creamer alternatives. How much eggnog to use will depend on your preference or the amount of creamer you usually use. However, the best way to add eggnog is by putting them to coffee less than you will with creamer.

The advised serving size is half a cup. Add only a quarter cup so it will not overwhelm the original flavor of the coffee. You can always add more eggnog later.


Eggnog as coffee creamers isn’t unheard of. There are many available brands, coming in different types and sizes. You can also make your own at home.

If you’re health-conscious, you can try fat-free, non-dairy, and low-fat eggnogs. These alternatives have less flavor, thickness, and creaminess.

Is It Safe to Use Eggnog As Coffee Creamer?

Although eggnog’s main ingredients (eggs, milk, cream, and sugar) seem like an unhealthy combination, it’s loaded with fats, calories, and sugar needed in the body. If you’re afraid of salmonella, using pasteurized liquid eggs or cooking the eggs will kill all potential bacteria.

It’s safe to consume eggnog as long as you stick to its recommended serving size and take it in moderation. You can also make it healthier by choosing alternatives to lower the sugar intake. However, weight gain and allergies are eggnog’s most common side effects. 

Other than the benefits of drinking coffee, here are the other health benefits of drinking eggnog coffee:

  • It provides omega-3 fatty acids that help to prevent cardiovascular diseases.
  • Organic milk has saturated fats that lower a person’s cholesterol.
  • It contains calcium needed for strong bones, hair, teeth, and nails.
  • Milk also improves healthy eye function.

Homemade Recipes of Eggnog Creamer And Eggnog Coffee

Christmas Bombardino cocktail with egg liqueur
You can make your own eggnog in your home

Here are the homemade recipes for eggnog creamer and eggnog coffee.

Eggnog Creamer


  • One and a half cups of half-and-half
  • One teaspoon of vanilla extract
  • Half a cup of condensed milk
  • Half a teaspoon of rum extract
  • Half a teaspoon of nutmeg 


  • Bowl and spoon or whisker for mixing
  • Jar or container


  1. Combine the condensed milk and half and half in a bowl. Mix well.
  2. Add the rum and vanilla and mix again.
  3. Grab the nutmeg, sprinkle them, and whisk to mix well.
  4. Pour the completed mixture into a container and store. Remember to shake well before using them in your coffee.

Eggnog Coffee


  • Espresso shot
  • Half a cup of milk of choice
  • A quarter cup of eggnog
  • Nutmeg and cinnamon (optional)


  • Milk frother or whisk
  • Spoon
  • Pot
  • Glass or cup


  1. Grab the pot and heat the milk on the stove until it’s warm but not boiling. Use a microwave if you want to.
  2. Froth the warm milk until it becomes foamy. 
  3. Take a spoon to remove the foam and set it aside.
  4. Pour the freshly brewed espresso into the cup and add warm milk and eggnog. Stir and mix well.
  5. Place the milk foam on top. 
  6. Optional: Add cinnamon sticks or freshly grated nutmeg.

FAQs About Eggnog And Coffee

Can You Mix Eggnog With Hot Coffee?

Yes, you can use eggnog as a coffee creamer in your cup of Joe to upgrade its usual flavor.

Can You Put Holiday Nog In Coffee?

You’ll find that adding nog to your coffee is a game-changer. It’s tasty and much better than your regular coffee creamer. But of course, this will still depend on your preference. 

How many eggnogs Do You Add To Coffee?

It depends on the recipe or your preference. But it is recommended to add a half cup or less of eggnog for a better and balanced taste of coffee.

Can You Put Eggnog In Iced Coffee?

Yes, you can put eggnog in both hot and iced coffee. To do that, fill your glass with ice cubes and pour coffee. Add eggnog, mix, and enjoy.


  • Maria Caballero

    Writer and coffee lover, Maria Caballero, is fond of visiting new cafes and trying current trends involving caffeine. She shares amusing experiences to fellow coffee enthusiasts who wants to explore the world of coffee.