5 Best Coffee Syrups For Making Professional Beverages At Home

Do you want to make your coffee, latte, or espresso taste a bit better in the morning? If so, take a look at the best coffee syrups options!

Adding caramel topping to latte macchiato - Best Coffee Syrups
The best coffee syrups elevate the taste of your beverages

Many people cannot wake up in the morning without a delicious cup of coffee. One of the best parts of going to a coffee shop is looking at the different flavored syrups, including hazelnut, french vanilla, and caramel flavor, deciding what you want to put in your coffee that morning.

If you want to save money, you may want to make your cup of coffee at home. Just because you aren’t at a coffee shop doesn’t mean you can’t enjoy a shot of caramel syrup in your iced coffee! If you want to make your iced coffee taste like a peppermint mocha from Starbucks, look at some of the best syrup options below.

What To Look For In The Best Coffee Syrups

adding caramel to iced coffee
There are several factors to consider when looking for the best coffee syrup

If you are looking for the best coffee syrup, you will quickly realize plenty of options is available. Regardless of whether you are looking for pumpkin spice, lavender syrup, or even an Irish Cream syrup, there are several important factors to consider. They include:

The Ingredients

Some people have a variety of dietary restrictions. You might be looking for gluten-free, natural, preservative-free, non-GMO, or even sugar-free syrups. If you are looking for an all-natural option, you may look for a coffee syrup with pure cane sugar. 

The Reviews

Always look at what other people say if you are looking for the best syrups. If other people have had a good experience, you will probably have a good experience as well.

Your Drinks

Some syrups will taste better in certain beverages than others. Think about your favorite options from your local coffee shop, and try to find a coffee syrup with a flavor that will match. You might be looking for white chocolate, chocolate sauce, or even a nice buttery flavor. 

The Brand’s Reputation

Pay attention to the brand’s reputation as well. You might be interested in an Amoretti, Torani syrup, or even Monin syrups. These are just a few coffee syrup brands that have some of the best reputations in the industry.

These are just a few of the many factors that coffee lovers need to consider as they are looking for a coffee flavoring syrup. 

You might also be interested in our guide on what is Carajillo.

How To Pick The Best Coffee Syrups

As you try to pick the best coffee syrup to meet your needs, there are a few tips you should keep in mind. They include:

  • Always look at multiple outlets before you decide what to buy. That way, you make sure you are getting the best deal possible.
  • Take the flavor on the label with a grain of salt. Just because it says that it tastes like gingerbread doesn’t mean your flavored latte will turn out the same. Take a look at what other people have to say.
  • Always take a look at how long the syrup will last. If your hazelnut syrup expires a week after you buy it, you may want to go with a different option. Coffee syrups typically have the best buy date between three and six months from the date of purchase.
  • Consider buying in bulk if the syrup will last a long time. That way, you can save money.

1. Best Coffee Syrup Overall: The Torani Variety Pack

If you are looking for the best coffee syrup overall, you should pay attention to this variety pack from Torani. It contains a wide variety of flavors, including French vanilla, hazelnut, caramel, and more. While you’re at it, check out the best mocha glasses for flavored drinks.

Torani is one of the most trusted names in the industry, and it isn’t easy to do much better than this variety pack. You will have just about every flavor you can imagine, and you can add them to your cup of coffee in the morning.

Pros

  • You have a nice variety with this pack
  • Because you get four bottles, they will last a long time
  • The bottles are made using pure cane sugar

Cons

  • You may not need four bottles of this size
  • The syrup may lose its flavor before you can use it all
  • Even though you save money per bottle, buying four bottles at once can be expensive
Torani Variety Pack Caramel, French Vanilla, Vanilla & Hazelnut
$36.01 ($0.35 / Fl Oz)
  • Caramel, French Vanilla, Vanilla & Hazelnut
  • 25.4 Ounces (Pack of 4)
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
11/26/2022 10:20 pm GMT

2. The Best Coffee Syrup For Organic Lovers: Monin Organic Vanilla

If you are looking for an organic coffee syrup, you may want to check out this option from Monin. Monin as a brand has a solid reputation, and this vanilla coffee syrup has been made using organic cane sugar. It has also been made using organic vanilla bean extract. 

This coffee syrup will also meet a variety of other dietary restrictions. It is kosher, gluten-free, vegan, and has not been made using any GMO ingredients. 

Even though this can be a bit more expensive than some of the other options, it is one of the cleanest coffee syrups on the market. This doesn’t necessarily mean that it is healthier, as it still contains a lot of sugar.

Pros

  • It has been made using natural ingredients without artificial preservatives or flavors
  • The main ingredient is organic cane sugar
  • It is also gluten-free, vegan, kosher, and non-GMO

Cons

  • This is one of the most expensive options on the market
  • Some people may not like just how sweet it is
  • It does not last as long as some of the other syrups, as it expires sooner
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
11/27/2022 01:50 pm GMT

3. Best Coffee Syrup For Sugar-Free Options: Jordans Skinny Syrups, Irish Cream

If you are looking for sugar-free coffee syrup, you understand how difficult this can sometimes be. Not every sugar-free option tastes good, and some of them can be downright disappointing. Fortunately, you can enjoy a delicious sugar-free coffee syrup with this option from Jordans.

If you are familiar with what whiskey and cream taste like, that is exactly what you will get with this option. Of course, this option does not have any alcohol, and it is also free from all sugar and calories. It is sweetened with sucralose, so it will still taste delicious. You might also be interested in our round-up of the best coffee creamers.

Pros

  • It’s sugar-free and 0-calorie
  • Even though it uses sucralose, it still tastes good
  • It gives you good value for your money

Cons

  • Some people may develop an upset GI tract because of the sucralose in this option
  • It still doesn’t taste as good as pure cane sugar
  • Not everyone likes the taste of Irish cream
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
11/27/2022 06:31 am GMT

4. Best Coffee Syrup For Indulging: Ghirardelli Squeeze Bottles

If you are ready to indulge in something incredibly sweet and decadent, then you should check out this option from Ghirardelli. You get three bottles in this package. This includes chocolate, white chocolate, and caramel.

They come in convenient squeeze bottles packed with a tremendous amount of flavor. The ingredients include real chocolate, real cocoa butter, and real caramel. These are premium sauces, and you do not need to use a lot to get the flavor spike you are looking for.

Even though they may not last as long on the shelf as some other choices, you might add to the shelf life by putting them in the refrigerator.

Pros

  • They pack a tremendous amount of flavor into a relatively small package
  • You get access to three different, delicious flavors in this variety pack
  • You get good value for your money

Cons

  • They do not last as long as some of the other options
  • Some people may find a flavor to be a bit too strong in a morning coffee
  • They are not nearly as healthy as some of the other options on this list
Ghirardelli Squeeze Bottles - Caramel, Chocolate & White Chocolate
$26.99 ($0.54 / Ounce)
  • Ghirardelli Premium Sauce (Pack of 3)
  • 1 - 16 oz Bottle of each: Chocolate Sauce, Caramel Sauce, White Chocolate Flavored Sauce
  • Perfectly formulated for use in espresso-based drinks, these sauces are also great in hot chocolate and as ice cream or dessert toppings
  • The gold standard for making exceptional mochas and amazing baked goods. Made with real Ghirardelli chocolate, cocoa powder, sugar, and vanilla
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
11/26/2022 12:05 pm GMT

5. Best Coffee Syrup For Concentrates: Autocrat Coffee Syrup

Many people try to stay away from corn syrup, but if you are looking for a cheap concentrate you can add, you should check out this option from Autocrat. This is a large bottle, it contains high fructose corn syrup as the main sweetener, and you will get rid of any bitterness in your coffee. Of course, it is certainly not the healthiest option available, but it is one of the least expensive.

Remember that you do not need to add a lot to sweeten your coffee, and it will last a pretty long time. You can use this syrup to make the original Frappuccino from the coffee shop Coffee Connection in Cambridge, MA.

Pros

  • It is incredibly sweet, so you do not need to use it a lot
  • It will last a long time on the shelf
  • You can use it to create something similar to the original Frappuccino

Cons

  • Many people try to stay away from high fructose corn syrup
  • It is packed with a tremendous number of carbohydrates
  • It contains a lot of artificial flavors and preservatives
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
11/26/2022 08:15 pm GMT

Testing Criteria

Businessman holding a clipboard and writing notes
Consider the flavor, value for money, and shelf-life when choosing your coffee syrup

As we put together this list, there were several testing criteria that we followed to determine the best coffee syrups, such as: 

  • Flavor: We wanted to ensure the coffee syrup provided an accurate flavor. In addition to tasting good, we wanted to make sure it matched what it said on the bottle. This is subjective, so we took multiple opinions into account.
  • Value for money: Even though we paid attention to the price, we paid closer attention to the value you got for your money. Some flavors are better than others, but there is a balance between the price and the quality of the flavor itself.
  • Shelf-life: We also took the shelf life into account. The longer the coffee syrup lasts, the better it is.

After considering these testing criteria, we put together a list above.

Why You Can Trust Me

There are several reasons why you can trust the opinions we’ve put together in this list. They include:

  • We have tried an unparalleled number of coffee syrups from companies worldwide.
  • We also have a lot of experience making various drinks, so we understand what flavors taste better in certain coffee drinks than others.
  • We took multiple people’s opinions into account before finalizing this list.

For all of these reasons, if you are looking for delicious coffee syrups, try some of the options above.

The Final Word on The Best Coffee Syrups

There is nothing wrong with a black cup of coffee or some straight cold drinks from time to time. On the other hand, if you are looking for a flavor shot, you may try some of the options above. 

The best coffee syrup overall is the Torani Variety Pack. You get four different flavors in a single package; the coffee syrup has natural ingredients and features pure cane sugar. Do not hesitate to branch out and try some of the other options on this list, but the Torani Variety Pack is the best coffee syrup overall.

Author

  • David R

    Job experience includes extensive work as a teaching assistant, tutor, and guest lecturer and extensive employment in the healthcare field. Have published multiple research papers and numerous poster presentations on various healthcare research topics.