What’s The Best Coffee For Tiramisu? Top 3 Picks

Wondering how to find the best coffee for tiramisu? This article explores what qualities to look for and offers suggestions on coffees to choose for making the dessert of your dreams.

3 glass of tiramisu dessert - best coffee for tiramisu

Tiramisu is a unique dessert: decadent and light simultaneously, with a signature coffee flavor. It’s like the offspring of an English trifle, an American cheesecake, a French chocolate mousse, and Italian espresso all rolled into one. 

Since one of the key ingredients in a traditional tiramisu is coffee, choosing the right one is essential. A few key things to understand about the coffee go into a proper tiramisu and a few factors to look for in the coffee you choose.

Read on to learn more about the best coffee for tiramisu!

Coffee In Tiramisu: Simple and Complicated

Classic tiramisu has a concise list of ingredients: ladyfinger cookies (also known as Savoiardi in Italy), egg yolks, sugar, coffee, mascarpone cheese, cocoa powder, and sometimes liquor. The preferred choices for liquor in tiramisu include brandy, rum, marsala wine, and coffee liqueurs such as Kahlua. Still, some chefs like to twist things a bit by using an orange liqueur like Cointreau, triple sec, or an almond liqueur like amaretto.

Mascarpone in glass bowl, ingredients for tiranisu
Tiramisu has a very short list of ingredrients

I have a friend who swears on using Frangelico, an Italian hazelnut liqueur. So there are plenty of twists and complexities you can add to your tiramisu, as long as you keep the other elements in balance. And the critical element to keep in balance is coffee.

The coffee that goes into tiramisu needs to be strong to balance the richness of the mascarpone, egg yolk, and sugar. Typically, recipes for this classic dessert use a mixture of strong brewed coffee and instant espresso–but you can also use regular brewed coffee on its own or brewed espresso from a Moka pot, diluted with a little bit of water.

If you love tiramisu but need to cut back on your coffee intake, check out our post on making tiramisu without coffee.

If you liked this post, you might enjoy learning about the best options for a coffee drink with rum.

Not Just Any Coffee Will Do

Technically, you can use any strongly brewed coffee mixed with espresso powder to make your tiramisu syrup. The syrup then soaks into the ladyfingers, forming a significant flavor component for your dessert. You want coffee that’s strong in flavor to help marry the richness of the mascarpone and eggs with the sweetness of the ladyfingers and the sugar in the dessert. 

A bag of dark roasted coffee beans on a wooden table
Opt for a strong coffee

A medium to dark roast works perfectly: the flavor profile for dark roasts is assertive and bold. It often tends towards chocolate and caramel notes, blending everything in your finished dessert. On the other hand, a light roast, even brewed strong, would lose its character in the richness and end up tasting weak.

Consider Darker Roasts for Your Tiramisu

Many tiramisu recipes emphasize using expresso or robust coffee. Dark roasts are the best way to go due to their bold flavor. Medium-dark and maybe even medium can be used, but it’s not advised to go any lighter than that.

A light roast probably won’t have the same flavor profile you typically associate with tiramisu. 

My Picks For Best Coffee For Tiramisu

For premium tiramisu, you want a strong, bold coffee with rich flavor to stand up to the other components in the dessert. Dark and extra-dark roasts make an excellent choice, especially with African beans.

Here are my favorites:

1. Peet’s Coffee Organic French Roast

Italian roast might be traditional, but french roasts are just as dark, with the same level of complexity on average. Peet’s Organic French Roast blends beans from Guatemala and Colombia to enhance the bright acidity that coffee can bring to the table.

In addition, the dark roast enhances caramel flavors, making for a slightly bitter brew for drinking, but one that’s perfect for balancing the sweet and creamy flavors of your tiramisu.

Peet's Coffee, Dark Roast Whole Bean Coffee - Organic French Roast 18 Ounce Bag, USDA Organic
  • Contains one (1) 18 Ounce Bag of Peet's Organic French Roast Whole Bean 100% Arabica Coffee. Pakaging may vary for a limited time.
  • Flavor and Roast: Dark Roast. Chocolate truffle, smoke, caramel. A meticulously grown, deep-roasted coffee that is a bold dedication to flavor, farm, and future
  • Brewing Methods: Use fine ground coffee for espresso at home. Coarsely ground coffee (consistency of coarse sea salt) can be used to make cold brew or a French press. Use a medium grind (consistency of sand) for drip or a pour over in your Chemex
  • Incomparable Organics: Our organic coffees must not only pass USDA Organic certification; they must meet our own exacting standards for quality and exceptional flavor
  • Freshness You Can Fact Check: Freshly roasted coffee means a more flavorful cup. We print the roast date on each and every bag for maximal transparency, and ensure you receive it within 90 days for the optimal experience

2. Lavazza Crema E Gusto

Lavazza is a famous name in Italian espresso, and this dark roast provides good evidence for why that is. Indonesian and Latin American beans offer a spicy, earthy punch with a soft caramel-like finish. The blend of beans also lends itself nicely to espresso, with a creamy texture that comes across even when you brew with automatic drip–but that comes across exceptionally well with a Moka pot or espresso machine.

Sale
Lavazza Crema E Gusto Whole Bean Coffee Dark Roast 2lb Bag, Crema E Gusto, 2lb ,Authentic Italian, Blended and roasted in Italy, Full-bodied dark roast with creamy and full-bodied, with spices notes
  • Full-bodied dark roast with creamy and full-bodied, with spices notes
  • Dark Roast
  • Blended and roasted in Italy
  • Suitable for brewing in any coffee maker
  • 1 2.2 pound bag of Lavazza crema E gusto whole bean coffee

3. Stumptown Coffee Roasters Holler Mountain

While this blend is technically a medium roast, Stumptown tends to produce a darker medium.” The complex flavors still provide a punch. Holler Mountain features Latin American and East African beans roasted to a medium-dark finish. The combination highlights citrus, hazelnut, and caramel notes–just what you’d want for tiramisu.

The brew you make from this coffee can more than stand up to the rich, creamy flavor of the mascarpone cream while balancing the sweetness of the ladyfingers and the sharp taste of the cocoa powder.

Stumptown Coffee Roasters, Medium Roast Organic Whole Bean Coffee - Holler Mountain 12 Ounce Bag with Flavor Notes of Citrus Zest, Caramel and Hazelnut
  • Contains one (1) 12 Ounce Bag of Stumptown Holler Mountain Organic Whole Bean Coffee
  • Holler Mountain: This organic blend has been a hometown favorite since day one. It’s got the complexity to pour a great espresso yet the versatility to serve as your daily cup of drip
  • Flavor: Holler Mountain delivers a burst of citrus and berry jam rounded out with notes of creamy caramel. 100% Arabica coffee
  • Direct Trade: Our Direct Trade program is built on three principles: pay higher prices tied to quality; work with producers we know and maintain those relationships over many years; strive to build truly collaborative partnerships
  • Brewing Methods: How you brew - from espresso to cold brew to pour over - the grinder you use, and yes, even the water from your sink, can alter the taste in the cup. Play around with the parameters to get each coffee to taste just how you like it.

Author

  • Aisling is an Irish food and drinks writer and journalist fueled by coffee and herbal tea. She followed up her journalism degree with nutrition studies.